In 1970, I recall driving over the Verranzano-Narrows bridge with my
parents to attend my first dog show, The Staten Island Kennel Club. The
tenting was visible from the bridge and what a beautiful sight it was!
We were to meet with a Dane breeder, as for reasons beyond the
understanding of my family, when our household pet of thirteen years
passed away, I decided that I wanted a Great Dane. At that show I
remember holding one of Pat Morris' champion dogs as he was waiting for
his class, as well as one of Hank Thunhorst's beautiful bitches. Hank
pointed out the top handlers in the nation, Bob and Jane Forsyth, who
created quite an impression on me.
The following weekend, we were to take the drive upstate to meet Hank at
Rosemarie Robert's Dinro Kennels. "Going to the mountain" is what Dane
people called this, as Rose lived up an unpaved road atop a mountain
surrounded by state park. I thought I wanted a fawn bitch; however, I
ended up with a brindle dog. We were to pick up the puppy a few weeks
later, after he had grown a bit. The morning we were to leave. I was
sitting on our front porch and a kind of beagle/basset mix trotted from
across the street from a park. The dog climbed up the steps to the porch
and sat down, all nice and comfortable, as if he belonged there. My dad
said, "Well, Eric, would you like to keep this dog or go today to pick
up the Great Dane?" Little did I know what a turn my life would take by
my answer to that question.
This shy, yet precocious kid from Brooklyn proceeded to show his Great
Dane. I was able to put several points on “Royal” in competition with
some of the top pros of the day and qualified for the Junior Showmanship
finals at the Garden twice.
I had wanted for some time to gain experience by working for Mrs.
Robert, but she was so intimidating that I always was too frightened to
ask. I decided one afternoon when I got home from school, I was going to
call her and ask her for a job, no matter how nervous I was. I got home,
immediately went to the phone, dialed the number, and she answered. I
asked if she needed some help at the kennel for the summer. The ten
seconds of dead silence that followed seemed like an eternity. Finally,
she said, "You don't expect to get paid, do you?" When I reassured her
that it was the good, solid experience that I was after, she said it
would be OK.
Several weekends later, my parents dropped me off at Dinro. Rose was
away at a show. There was a part-time kennel person (gender not readily
discernable, but since her name was “Eleanor”, I took a guess at “she”)
who handed me a glove-brush and mumbled that I should start brushing the
Danes. As Eleanor warmed up to me, she informed me the main kennel
person and handler had gone on a 'bender' the previous week and was
fired because she had left a gate open allowing two of Rose' s favorite
males to get together in a wicked fight. Several hours later, Rose
returned from the show with several breeders and judges in tow. She
introduced me to the group by announcing, "Meet my new handler". Well, I
think my heart sank into my stomach. The next duty for this 14 year old
was to act as bartender and serve cocktails to the guests.
Every other day at Dinro was like a dog show. People would come from all
over to make the “pilgrimage” to Dinro. Rose would let people leave
their puppies loose in her living room. She was disappointed when they
left, even if it was at 2:00 in the morning. As intimidating as she
could be, if she saw that a person had a sincere interest in the breed,
she would open up and the knowledge would start to flow. She was a
Cooper Union graduate. Above the mantle of her fireplace were three Dane
heads she had sketched. You would swear they were photographs.
I wish people today had the opportunity to avail themselves to old time
breeders. Every breed had them. This was the best learning experience.
I'm afraid its gone by the wayside, and commercialism and mediocrity to
some degree have taken its place. Fortunately, there are breeders today
who do have an eye and a knack for breeding dogs or we would not be
seeing the quality that we are seeing. The days of the big kennels are
gone. I feel so very fortunate that I was able to catch the tail-end of
During this period, I also showed a dog for Poppy and Al Feldman. I
believe they are two of the nicest people that I have ever known in or
out of dogs. Mr. Feldman, at that time was Chairman of the Board of the
American Kennel Club. His unparalleled ethics, integrity and calm gentle
manly manner are seldom seen in our society today.
I began handling professionally when I graduated from College and was
quite passionate about it. I was waiting until I turned twenty-one, as
in those days, you were considered an “outlaw handler” if you showed
dogs for others and accepted any type of payment. Just three months
before I turned twenty-one, the AKC stopped the licensing of handlers,
so I started a bit early. I completed championships on about one-hundred
Danes, including some Number One Danes and some influential producers. I
had some successes in other breeds, as well. My first Special, Ch.
Tilpadane Barnaby Neustadt, won the breed at the Garden and went on to
many wins. He had true Dane temperament and was a pleasure to show. My
next one, Ch. Bodane Tourister, would prefer to be at home, having fun
and lying on the couch. “Tory” also won the breed at the Garden and
became the Top Male Dane in the Country, as did “Barnaby”. He produced
about thirty to forty champions. When reading through a Top Twenty
catalog a few years ago, I realized the profound effect “Tory” had on
the breed. Almost every top Dane in the country goes back to him, most
of them several times.
moved from New York to California and showed there through the 80's.
During this time Dane activities were becoming progressively more
national in scope. Our National formerly was always held at Westchester
in Tarrytown, NY. With entries going up every year, we eventually
outgrew the one-day National, and began to alternate to various regions
nationwide. The annual Dinner/Dance used to be the Saturday prior to
Westminster. Now, it is one of the many events during a week-long
My handling activities continued in California and it was a good life. I
met many people and showed a lot of dogs. My favorite was “Higgins”, Ch.
Reann's No Jacket Required, who was a nice combination of East and West
coast lines. His intelligence and temperament really got to me. It was
as if he could read my mind. Californians were a fun group of people. I
still enjoy going out for a visit from time to time.
I was beginning get a bit tired of the traveling as well as the vagaries
of the profession, when in 1990, I was offered a position with the
American Kennel Club as Administrator of Judge's Education. This gave
me the opportunity to return to New York and live in Manhattan. I worked
during the Bob Maxwell administration and directly under Terry Stacey.
This was a good time, in my opinion, for the AKC. I was also allowed to
focus on my tasks, and never had to become involved with politics.
Fortunately, both Jim Crowley and Dennis Sprung are still there so, I
think things should stay in relatively good shape.
My main function at AKC was to produce the Breed Standard Video Series.
I produced about half of all of the breeds, Midge Martin was my
predecessor and she did the other half. It was a great experience.
Just think of the top breeders in each breed and dogs assembling from
throughout the country. We did eight breeds every six months, so the
work on each video was about three weeks long. It was a unique
education. Working with the committees was always interesting. On more
than one occasion, a committee member would call me to inform me that
they could not possibly work with “so-and-so” on the same committee. By
the time they got through the script meeting or an editing session, they
would come to realize that most had the common interest of their breed
at heart, and how much they were of the same opinion after all. Some of
these people who had not spoken in 20 years, after a meeting would be
off together to a New York City restaurant or to see a Broadway play.
When I decided to leave the AKC, a few of my co-workers took me to lunch
and brought up the prospect of judging. It made sense, as my position
at AKC was sort of like having my own private college for the job. The
following morning there was a FedEx package with nine breed applications
on my doorstep. I applied for eight breeds. After almost ten years now,
I do the Working and Herding Groups and about one-third of the Sporting.
I really enjoy judging. The other judges are very helpful and
supportive. I worry about the sport's future, as some of our most
beloved judges are getting up there in years. There are many good, new
dedicated judges but I'm afraid there are also those who attend seminars
and participate in the in-ring observing just to check off the right
boxes on the application and have no real talent for judging. I suppose
however that there have always been all levels of quality in judging,
just like anything else.
I consider my approach to judging as being basically scientific, with a
touch of art added in the equation. It is a challenge to apply the breed
standards to the living animals that you see before you on a given day.
I try to imagine a couple of old-timers in the breed that I'm judging
watching me to see whether or not I'm doing justice to their breed.
My friends who show under me in my own breed understand that I am just
evaluating the dogs on the day. Sometimes, a friend whose dog does not
win may cop a bit of an attitude, but it is soon forgotten. I have to
remind myself that I was sometimes fairly intense when I was showing.
People in other breeds, who do not yet know me, appear to settle down a
bit when they realize that I am just trying to do an honest job, with
the points of the breed standard in mind.
All in all, it's been a fun ride. I've met a lot of good people and
have many fond memories. I do wonder from time to time where I would be
and what I would be doing if I had chosen the other option presented to
me at age thirteen when the beagle/bassett made its' way onto our front